subscribe: Posts | Comments      Facebook      Email Steve

Ten Napa Valley wineries that should be better known



It happens all the time in wine: famous wineries overshadow the less famous. Bordeaux set the pattern: So luminous is the glare of the most celebrated Classified Growths that some perfectly fine chateaux are obscured. It being the purpose of wine writers to bring under-appreciated wineries to readers’ attention, here are my suggestions. I don’t mean to suggest that these wineries are coming out of the blue. Insiders know them; it’s the general public that doesn’t.

Goldschmidt Vineyards. Veteran winemaker Nick Goldschmidt’s carefully crafted Cabernets rival the best of Napa Valley. But for some reason, they haven’t garnered the acclaim of competitors such as Staglin or Dalla Valle. Representative wine: 2006 Game Ranch “Plus” Cabernet Sauvignon, Oakville; $150, 98 points.

Terra Valentine. I’ve been giving this winery high scores since the late 1990s. They do a fantastic job with their Spring Mountain fruit, but you seldom hear of them in the same breath as the cults. Representative wine: 2010 K-Block Cabernet Sauvignon, Spring Mountain; $65, 95 points.

B. Cellars. The winery really caught my eye with their 2004 vintage, and I’ve been a fan ever since. Cabernet is the speciality, although they also try their hand at Syrah and Chardonnay. Representative wine: 2009 Beckstoffer To Kalon Cabernet Sauvignon, Oakville; $165, 95 points.

Summers Estate. Calistoga-based Summers has been crafting terroir wines of distinction since at least the late 1990s. But the last 10 years have really shown the fruits of success, not just with Cabernet but with Zinfandel, Petite Sirah and Charbono. Representative wine: 2010 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, Calistoga; $50, 92 points.

Sodaro Estate. I felt this winery’s struggle in the mid-2000s, but by the 2008 and 2009 vintages, they started to rock. That may have been due to the involvement of May-Britt and Denis Malbec, the consulting winemakers. Representative wine: 2009 Doti/Sodaro Blocks 2 and 6 Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley; $125, 95 points.

Amici. This is former Beaulieu winemaker Joel Aiken’s baby, and while it took him a while to find his footing, he’s now established it securely. A flagship wine is certainly the 2009 Morisoli Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon, Rutherford; $125, 95 points. But for the representative wine, I’m choosing Amici’s 2007 Olema Cabernet, Napa Valley; $20, 97 points. It stood out in a blind tasting several years ago of more than 60 Napa Cabs, almost all of which cost far more.

Prime Cellars. The celebrated winemaker, Ted Henry (Jarvis), and his wife, Lisa, own the brand, and he crafts the wines (she does the marketing). With the sole exception of a so-so 2005 Cab and a 2008 Chardonnay, I’ve given all their releases 90 points or higher. Representative wine: 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon, Coombsville; $64, 93 points.

KaDieM. This is a brand new brand, a partnership between friends. The winemaker is Michael Trujillo, who was mentored by the likes of André Tchelistcheff and Tony Soter. The representative wine is their 2009 Inaugural Vintage Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley; $85, 95 points.

Patland Estate. Winemaker Jay Buoncristiani [ex-Hess Collection] crafts rich Cabs, Syrahs and Malbecs from the winery’s estate vineyard and from purchased grapes, notably the Stagecoach Vineyard, which straddles the Atlas Peak AVA. Representative wine: 2009 Stagecoach Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley; $90, 94 points.

Turnbull Wine Cellars. Turnbull isn’t new. In fact, it was one of the first wineries I ever wrote about [in its Johnson-Turnbull era]. Although the winery is set on Highway 29 in the heart of Oakville, its wines tend to pass unnoticed, which is really a pity. Representative wine: 2009 Black Label Cabernet Sauvignon, Oakville; $100, 95 points.

  1. Bill Haydon says:

    Average Price: $91.40/bottle.

    Number of wines at less than $50/bottle: 1

    Average Price of the Remaining 9: $111.75

  2. doug wilder says:

    I remember the 1987 Johnson Turnbull Lot 67 Cabernet Sauvignon (made by Kristen Belair) was very memorable and reminded me of Heitz Martha’s. I also consistently like what Patland is putting out. I would add Emerson Brown and Culler to that list to try if you haven’t yet.

  3. Bill, I guess you get what you pay for.

  4. Doug Wilder, they used to call Lot 67 “the poor man’s Heitz Martha’s Vineyard.” The mintiness was said to come from giant old eucalyptus trees that surrounded the vineyard.

  5. What timing, Steve! Just finished a tasting with Nick Goldschmidt. Great guy who loves talking about the nuances and finer points of winemaking from different regions around the world. Funny as hell and very talented winemaker. The new releases of Goldschmidt Vineyards wines were amazing! With less than 100 cases of the GV “Plus” Cabernets made, not a lot to go around, so it won’t break my heart if they stay under the radar.

  6. Bill Haydon says:

    “Bill, I guess you get what you pay for.”

    Yet fewer and fewer people are willing to pay it with each passing year, Steve. I spent a miserable year consulting for a group of Napa wineries, including a few names that would probably shock you. Those wines are literally dead men walking in the market. If I was a salesman in New York or Chicago who had to pay my bills taking those, and other similar, wines around, I would go home and stick my head in the oven.

    And while I generally consider your commentary, while undoubtedly pro-California, to be still be thoughtful and nuanced compared to a few of the kool-aid drinkers out there, the sentiment in that quote is a huge part of the difficulties and market travails that they are facing.

  7. Bill H: Your incisive commentary points to the core problem of wine criticism: the purveyors never have to buy the wines they feature and consume.

  8. Regarding Sodaro wines, please note the transition to Denis and May-Britt was about four months ago, so through the 2012 vintage winemaking was by Dyer Consulting (mainly Dawnine).

  9. Thanks Bill Dyer for pointing that out.

  10. Bill Haydon says:

    Or sell them, Tom!

  11. Thanks for including Patland Estate Vineyards, we’re honored! When will you visit us for a full tasting experience?

  12. Steve, nice comments regarding Nick Goldschmidt, could not agree more. You need to be aware he is not an “Aussie”, Nick is from New Zealand.

  13. Oops. Corrected.

  14. Hey Steve, you left out Napa’s oldest hidden gem and my FAVORITE winery, Nichelini Family Winery. They are the oldest same family owned and operated winery in Napa Valley and second oldest in California, I beleive they are going on 123 years this year. If you haven’t been yet, this is a must visit, great wines, someone from the family is always there with stories, a great escape from the typical valley floor wineries.

  15. Thank you, Steve! It’s great to be included with this impressive list of wineries. As you know, Amici Cellars is no newcomer to Napa Valley and we’re so happy to have Joel Aiken as part of the group making some great wine for us.

  16. Dear Carol B, sorry. My list wasn’t meant to be inclusive!

  17. Oh, the struggles of those poor Napa wineries.

  18. Elizabeth Phillips says:

    I am so happy to see this list. It is especially exciting to see Turnbull make the list. The wines are phenomenal and a great value as compared to many other wineries in the Oakville appellation. The representative wine is always a gem, but for those saying that the wines are expensive, Black Label is one of the higher price from the portfolio. Their Oakville Cabernet is impressive as well at almost half the price. I had the pleasure of working for the winery for a few years and I can say that I never had a problem selling those wines, especially in the major markets. The poor Napa wineries that over deliver for the price are not all hurting. Many are shining right now. It’s exciting to see.

  19. Thanks, Steve. We are honored and proud to be among this list. It’s nice to see some other favorites of mine, as well. The new 2010 KaDieM vintage is truly amazing. Nothing like three good friends with a passion for wine…Karen, Danna and Michael

  20. Cracking article .. I Love Napa, a real favorite of mine. Here’s my Intro to the area.

  21. Well done, Steve! So great to see several of these wineries featured on CellarPass as we definitely hit our recommendations list too.


  1. Weekly Link Love: August 19 | thefieryredhead - [...] Ten little-known Napa Valley wineries you should [...]
  2. An introduction to Napa Valley | cbgwine - [...] Ten Napa Valley wineries that should be better known ( [...]
  3. Napa Valley – Mount Veeder Winery 2010 Cabernet Sauvignon | Whine And Cheers For Wine - […] Ten Napa Valley wineries that should be better known ( […]

Leave a Reply


Recent Comments

Recent Posts